Creative news collection

Cloud-based LMS vs Self Hosted: Detailed Comparison

Aug 2, 2024

Reader Disclosure

If you look online for "How to promote online courses or classes," you'll be flooded with ads for various Learning Management Systems (LMS).

WHAT'S INSIDE          Toggle

Given how trendy online learning has become and how popular it is, there's no reason to wonder why so many different solutions are currently available.

But, with numerous options available, how do you decide which is the right one for you?

That's where this ever-evolving contrast between self-hosted and cloud-based LMSs comes in. Most importantly, LMSs are divided into the two types.

If you've completed the necessary research but are in a state of confusion about these two options there is a solution for you. In this blog, we'll discuss their differences and what one is best for you.

Cloud-based LMS vs Self Hosted A Comprehensive Comparison

As both self-hosted and cloud-based LMSs come with pros as well as cons, it all comes to the requirements you require. It is the reason you should carefully consider every element of an LMS, and decide the one you prefer.

However, in order to help you save time, we have done some study and have compared few key points in between the two.

User-Friendliness

 Cloud-based LMS:

Cloud-based LMSs aim to be easy to use even for those who aren't tech-savvy. Setup is generally straightforward. It will take just a few clicks to begin.

The provider you select to host your cloud-based LMS handles the maintenance and updates, meaning that you don't have to worry about how your servers are setup or how to address problems with the software. As a result, your focus is in creating your perfect course.

 Self-hosted LMS:

However setting up self-hosted LMS is more complicated. It requires setting up, configuring and regularly maintaining the system's content management, which can be difficult for people who aren't tech-savvy.

However, once the LMS is set up, customizing the LMS will become much simpler. Initial effort can be worth it because of the features for customization and additional functionalities self-hosted LMSs offer.

 Verdict

Cloud-hosted LMS might be sufficient in the case of building an LMS that has no plans or vision for growth. However, if you're looking for an extended period of growth, opt for the self-hosted option although the initial configuration process may be difficult.

Security

 Cloud-based LMS:

Security is the most important factor in the success of cloud-based LMS service providers. They take strong security measures, including encryption, firewalls, and regular security updates. They are always in compliance with rules and standards of the industry, such as GDPR and HIPAA.

However, ultimately it is the case that you're storing all the data you have on another server. This is an enormous privacy issue for a large number of individuals.

 Self-Hosted LMS:

When you host your own LMS, you have complete control of your security for data. You can implement customized security measures tailored to the specific needs of your company.

In accordance with what you're selling through your LMS as well as how much you'd like to concentrate in security. You'll have many options with self-hosted LMS. As a result, there is no need to sacrifice security concerns.

 Verdict

While cloud-based LMS offers strong security features however, the dependence on third-party servers can be problematic for some. To ensure that you're on the safer choice, choose the safer self-hosted LMS option.

All Control

 Cloud-Based LMS

Cloud-based LMS offers only limited control over the software. The majority of the time, you are restricted to the features of the vendor and configurations, which may limit customization and freedom.

You'll have difficulty with data management since there is no way to control the data. When you use the cloud-based LMS system, it's usually observed that the service provider manages user data and.

 Self-hosted LMS

A self-hosted LMS gives you the most control in comparison to those that are cloud-based. The software can be customized to meet your exact demands, and integrate it with other systems, and manage your data so you are able to provide top services to your customers.

This degree of control can help you gain credibility from your clients and make acquiring more users much easier.

 Verdict

For overall control Self-hosted LMSs are the best option. With a self-hosted LMS, you can fully modify and control every part of your LMS.

All Costs

 LMS that is cloud-based

The cost for cloud-based LMS generally is lower as there is no need to invest in hardware or set up infrastructure. But, these LMSs are also bundled with recurring subscription fees that can add up over time.

Certain cloud-based LMSs even charge according to the number of users. So, when the number of users grows, the price increases. This can become a problem after a certain period.

If you are planning in scaling your business or expanding your LMS website, the cloud-based LMS might not be the ideal choice.

 Self-Hosted LMS

Self-hosted LMSs are more expensive initially due to the need for server infrastructure, software licences, and setup. But once you have your own self-hosted LMS in operation then you won't need to spend any more money.

It is only necessary to plan for maintenance, hosting as well as occasional updates. This will amount to less than you would have spent on a cloud-based subscription.

 Verdict

For cost-effectiveness for cost-effectiveness, a self-hosted LMS typically provides greater return over time, in spite of the greater initial cost. It makes them an affordable option for use over the long term.

Flexibility and Integration

 Cloud-based LMS

Cloud-based LMS generally offer seamless integration with the top tools and services, but there may be limitations to the integrations offered by the service you select.

This is why you need to be aware of the integration facilities of your cloud-based LMS.

 Self-Hosted LMS

Self-hosted LMS has a wide range of integration possibilities. It is possible to integrate any third-party tools APIs, tools, or customized solutions as required. This flexibility allows you to build a custom learning experience that will meet the requirements of your particular needs.

 Verdict

In terms of flexibility and integration for integration and flexibility, a self-hosted LMS is the superior option. Its capability to be integrated with an array of tools will help you and your LMS in many ways.

Benefits of having Self-Hosted LMS for WordPress?

WordPress has been a blessing for those who love to be creative but are not into coding. Thanks to its drag-and-drop function coupled with an LMS plugin, you will be able to ensure the best possible experience for your customers.

Here are some of the most important benefits that come with self-hosted LMS for WordPress:

Control of Content

One of the greatest benefits with a self-hosted LMS is the fact that you are in total control of your content. You choose what to post the content, how it will be presented as well as who will be able to access the material.

This degree of control guarantees the course materials are protected and handled properly. Additionally, you can set up specific guidelines and rules to ensure that you follow the appropriate laws and company policy.

Branding and Personalization

WordPress provides more opportunities to make changes than other system, and you are able to let your LMS communicate your brand's message from every aspect.

With so many options of themes and applications to pick from, it is possible to make the user experience butter-smooth for users. By adding special tools and features to your LMS it will increase the engagement of the people who use it.

Additional Integration Options

With a simple integration process, your self-hosted LMS will grow and evolve with your business. Overall, it will never leave you feeling stuck.

An Enhanced Learning Environment

You can make your learning experience more engaging and exciting by taking advantage of the latest features in self-hosted LMS.

These features include videos, quizzes, a progress tracking bar, etc.

It is also possible to use gamification options like badges, leaderboards and other features to get students more interested and motivated. The overall learning experience will be more beneficial for your users when you select the self-hosted LMS platform to teach them.

Most Effective Methods for Building a Self-Hosted LMS

It offers extensive access control as well as content drip, seamless integration with a variety of payment gateways, making it ideal for monetizing your courses and providing a structured education experience.

But that's not all that makes amazing. You can:

  • Create and manage specific access policies to safeguard your data, and create different access levels effortlessly.
  • Plan the introduction of course content over the course of time to ensure that learners remain in the loop and are progressing steadily.
  • It supports a variety of payment gateways, including PayPal and Stripe, for efficient transactions.
  • Get comprehensive reports on the number of members, transactions and learner progress, giving you insight into how to enhance your course.
  • Set up the LMS tool with ease in just a few clicks.
  • Make your content more interactive so that your audience is more interested.

It's possible to start with for as low as $179.50/Year. To enjoy the pros, you'll have to shell out $499.50/Year.

MemberMouse

MemberMouse is a multi-faceted and robust WordPress plugin created to assist you create and manage websites for membership. Using this LMS allows you to secure your site's content, control different levels of membership, and integrate with other useful tools.

What this plugin has to offer:

  • A simple interface for setting up and managing memberships.
  • Advanced Content Protection to manage access to your courses.
  • Integration with the most popular payment processing platforms like Stripe, PayPal, and Authorize.net.
  • Flexible membership options, including trial or free memberships, as well as paid memberships.
  • Detailed reporting to track participation and activity by members.

It is possible to start using MemberMouse for $399/year. To access additional options and to have a bigger membership base, it could increase to $2399 per year.

AccessAlly

AccessAlly is an amazing LMS plugin that works with WordPress that combines members management, course development, and marketing automation. In addition to these features AccessAlly LMS offers a powerful community-building feature that most LMSs lack.

To name some of the AccessAlly attributes:

  • Design interactive and multimedia-rich classes easily.
  • Provide a range of membership levels and subscription plans.
  • Robust community features, such as forums and member directories, to encourage interaction and engagement.
  • Advanced reporting and analytics to keep track of the learning progress of students and their the effectiveness of the course.

AccessAlly pricing starts at $99/month, with more features and options available on higher levels.

Which is the most effective choice?

While LifterLMS and LearnDash have many useful features, LifterLMS it is by far the best choice for creating a self-hosted LMS using WordPress. Here's why:

  • Superior Access Control offers unmatched control of who has access to your website content. This allows highly customizable membership tiers and security of your content.
  • Affordable Content Dripping Ability to drip-feed content ensures that users receive the information they need regularly, promoting better retention and engagement.
  • Full Reporting Comprehensive reports of memberships, transactions, and learning progress will give you the information you need to fine-tune and improve your courses.
  • Easy Monetization: Seamless integration with various payment processors makes it simple to monetize your courses and manage the transactions.
  • User-Friendly Installation Although it has advanced features, is easy to setup and operate and is accessible for those without extensive technical knowledge.

Create a Self Hosted LMS using just 4 easy steps

Now that you know what you need to know about how to operate an LMS It's time to set it up. But before we dive into this, let's say that this isn't rocket science.

Step 1. Download and install

  • Login to the WordPress dashboard of your website.
  • Click Plugins and then Add New and then upload
  • Choose the .zip file you downloaded earlier

After installation, remember to activate the plugin.

If you've successfully activated , you'll get the menus displayed on your WordPress dashboard.

On within the Settingsmenu You can set up basic settings like payments gateways, currencies, and payment methods etc.

Step 2: Set up Membership levels

If you are developing an LMS, there will surely be multiple membership Levels and has no restrictions regarding this. It is possible to create any number of membership levels you'd like.

Go to Membership on the dashboard, and then click Add New.

Make sure that your membership has a suitable title, and don't forget what you would like the method of payment. It is possible to set up a one-time weekly, annual, or monthly payment.

If you wish, you can also add a welcome message to the users.

Once everything looks good When everything is in order, press publish and then your membership will be created. If you'd like to make several memberships, follow the steps.

Step 3: Upload Your Member Only Content

Navigate to Rulesfrom the dashboard, then click on Add New. In the next screen, you'll find dropdown menus for you to choose the rules that you'd like to create.

It is possible to create different rules for membership by repeating this process. When you're satisfied with the rules, click on Save Rule.

Step 4: Create a Pricing Page

The pricing page is a should-have for any Membership website to help the visitors decide on the plan that best suits their needs. This page also can encourage users to upgrade to a more expensive option by highlighting its additional features and benefits.

However, how do you design one?

So, you can be able to handle it so in the event that you're willing to invest the same amount of effort by clicking at least a couple of times.

For creating a pricing page, visit Groups in the dashboard, and click on Add New. Create a descriptive name and then go into the Group Options section:

Then, click"plus" (+) icon to include each of your memberships to this page. You are able to alter the order in which these plans show up in by dropping and dragging them onto the page:

Choose an appropriate theme by using the pricing page theme dropdown. Once you're happy with the result and you're ready to go live, you'll be able to post the webpage:

Your pricing page must be easy to access. Be sure to place it on the navigation menu at the top on the left, at the bottom, or even in the on the sidebar.

If you ensure that your pricing page is accessible, potential members can always be one click away from buying an agreement.

Cloud-Based or Self Hosted LMS? It's a fact that you Know already!

Hopefully, this blog helped to educate you about the differences between self-hosted and cloud-based LMS as well as which will be best for you. If you're really committed to your business and have a bigger picture in mind, a self hosted LMS solution might be your best choice.

While a myriad of choices are available, can be the best solution to your LMS requirements. From gathering leads for your LMS to detailed information about the members, they can aid to you in every phase.

Be sure to tell us about your experiences with different LMS solutions and which kind you like best.

If you've found this post informative, please connect with our page on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and LinkedIn!

S Showrabh       From composing poems or short stories, to writing technical articles regarding WordPress and managing an online membership website, a lot of things have changed for Showrabh. What did not change is his love of writing and the time he spends. He is a fan of football, music as well as cricket. He'll either sit for hours staring at his cell phone, or puts the headphones in and compose for long periods of time. When he's not doing either of these it is not uncommon to hear him explain the ways that one can enjoy both soccer and cricket at simultaneously.